Omar’s Mediterranean Cuisine: Authentic Flavors and Casual Dining in New York

We stumbled upon this place last year when we wanted to grab a quick bite since we had to rush to another place. It took us by surprise how amazing this was! You can tell that they are an old establishment. The food here is by far the best middle eastern I have had considering I am vegetarian. We always get the falafel platter to go but decided to dine in this time! They serve pita at the start, which was super soft & warm. I love everything about this place. It's food, & their hospitality. It's definitely special!

Vegan eats: Falafel sandwich with no white sauce Fries Healthy portions. Falafel moist not dry Complimentary hummus and pita soft and fresh Staff kind and friendly. One waiter for early evening patrons. He was busy but attentive.

Great service! We both got chix shawerma platters which comes with 2 sides. Heads up, they come with side salad, and we chose tabbouleh as one of the sides. Had we known about the side salad it came with already, we would have chosen a different side. We mentioned this to the gentleman at the register and he offered us another side. We got tzatziki and baba ghanoush! Both were delicious!! Kudos to staff for offering, this is true hospitality. Thank you Omars restaurant for an amazing meal and experience!!

3-Star Review for Omar’s Mediterranean Cuisine – 369 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY I recently dined at Omar’s Mediterranean Cuisine on Lexington Avenue and found it to be a decent experience, warranting three stars. The service was exceptional—friendly, attentive, and efficient, even during a busy time. The staff’s warmth made the visit pleasant. The restaurant was clean, which added to the overall positive impression. The food was flavorful with a great variety of side dish options. I ordered the spicy lamb platter with salad and beans, accompanied by a warm pita wrapped in foil and a complimentary piece of baklava for dessert. The lamb had a nice spicy kick, complemented well by the fresh salad and hearty beans. The pita was soft and warm, and the baklava was a sweet, flaky treat, though not particularly standout. Portions were medium but satisfying. On the downside, the seating was limited—there’s some, but not much, so finding a spot could be tricky during peak hours. The sauces were underwhelming, lacking the wow factor I’ve tasted at other Mediterranean spots. Overall, Omar’s offers a solid meal with excellent service and a clean environment, but the limited seating and average sauces keep it from being exceptional. I’d return for a quick bite if nearby, but it’s not a destination spot.

Omer’s Mediterranean Cuisine is a great spot for lunch with friends or colleagues—perfect for good conversation over a delicious meal. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making it easy to enjoy both the food and the company. On my first visit, I tried the Spicy Lamb Adana. It was cooked perfectly—juicy, flavorful, and just the right amount of heat. You could really taste the quality of the lamb in every bite. Definitely planning to come back to explore more of the menu. A solid choice for a satisfying Mediterranean lunch!

The food was very good and Authentic taste. The owner Omar was a kind man and greeted us after our food was done. No think twice must try it 100% halal arab food

One of the best Shwarma I have eaten in NYC. It’s busy because the food is excellent and the service is exceptional. I recommend everyone to try it and see for yourself. Whenever I’m in the city this is the place I’m always going to .

Wow!! Highly recommended this place amazing value for the amount of food you get. The entrees come with two sides which allows you to try a few different flavors. Our server was awesome and the place is very clean.